3 Best Arm & Hammer Toothpaste (Full Review)

Dentist Tested and Reviewed
Dr. Matthew Hannan | My Dental Advocate
Best Arm Hammer Toothpaste (Dentist Tested & Reviewed) | My Dental Advocate

Arm & Hammer has been a trusted brand for more than 170 years.

Their toothpaste line provides a wide range of care, including CompleteCare, PeroxiCare, and AdvancedWhite.

The Arm & Hammer toothpaste “experience” is unlike any other toothpaste; if you’re unfamiliar with it, you’re missing out. It’s highly foaming and “results you can feel working.”

As an experienced dentist with years of experience, I’ve tested and evaluated 300+ dental products. I strive to find the best products for achieving excellent oral hygiene, so let’s take a closer look at the Best Arm & Hammer Toothpaste from a dentist’s perspective.

Buying Guide

  1. Best Overall: Arm & Hammer PeroxiCare Toothpaste
  2. Best Whitening: Arm & Hammer Essentials Whiten & Strengthen Toothpaste
  3. Best Complete Care: Arm & Hammer CompleteCare Toothpaste

Alternative Options

  • Arm & Hammer Essentials Healthy Teeth & Gums Toothpaste
  • Arm & Hammer Essentials Whiten + Activated Charcoal Toothpaste
  • Arm & Hammer AdvancedWhite Toothpaste
  • Arm & Hammer Bright & Strong Truly Radiant Toothpaste
  • Arm & Hammer Sensitive Teeth & Gums Toothpaste
  • Arm & Hammer Rejuvenating Toothpaste
  • Arm & Hammer DentalCare Toothpaste

Toothpaste’s active and inactive ingredients have evolved significantly since its inception with the Egyptians around 4 AD. The Egyptians commonly used crushed rock salt, mint, and flowers to remove dental plaque and maintain healthy teeth.

Today, you will find difficult-to-pronounce ingredients, such as tetrasodium pyrophosphate. Each element serves an important purpose and is necessary for optimal performance.

Also, you will find a toothpaste that targets specific needs, including gum care, whitening, sensitive teeth, and deep cleaning.

Evaluation Criteria

I tested each product for 7-14 days, detailing its pros and cons, and rate it from 1 to 5 in four key areas.

  • Effectiveness: Does the toothpaste treat the advertised need? How effective were the results?
  • Comfort: Was the toothpaste comfortable? Was there any burning, stinging or uncomfortable sensation?
  • Taste: How was the overall taste? Was it refreshing? Did it alter your sense of taste?
  • Likeability: Is the toothpaste likable and enjoyable to use?

Related Reviews


1. Best Overall | Arm & Hammer PeroxiCare Toothpaste

Best Overall
Arm & Hammer Peroxicare Toothpaste
$8.99 ($0.75 / Ounce)

ARM & HAMMER™ Peroxicare™ anticavity fluoride toothpaste is the ultimate deep cleaning formula that improves gum health, protects against cavities and gently whitens teeth.

Naturally powered by 100% pure baking soda, this toothpaste goes beyond cleaning, giving you stronger, healthier teeth and gums.

Unlike regular fluoride toothpaste, the pure baking soda formulas penetrate deeper throughout your mouth, REMOVING UP TO 3X MORE PLAQUE in hard-to-reach places.

Buy Now
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
04/18/2024 11:03 pm GMT

Dentist Review

PeroxiCare provided the most foaming action when brushing, and the clean mint flavor was refreshing.

Similarly to CompleteCare, the texture was smooth and free of grit. Also, after rinsing, a slight cooling effect left our mouths feeling fresh and clean.

PeroxiCare was similar to CompleteCare in that there was less mint flavor and more baking soda, which was expected; however, Essentials Whiten & Strengthen had an outstanding balance of mint and baking soda flavors.

Highlights

  • Sodium fluoride 0.24%
  • Naturally powered by baking soda
  • Clean mint flavor
  • Baking soda and peroxide
  • Neutralizes plaque acid

Results

Effectiveness0
Comfort0
Taste0
Likability0
Total0

Best for patients desiring foaming action.


2. Best Whitening | Arm & Hammer Essentials Whiten & Strengthen Toothpaste

Best Whitening
Arm & Hammer Essentials Whiten & Strengthen Toothpaste
$24.30 ($1.41 / Ounce)

ARM & HAMMER Essentials Fluoride Toothpaste Whiten & Strengthen is full of what you need and free of what you don’t.

ARM & HAMMER Essentials Whiten & Strengthen is made with 100% natural baking soda to whiten teeth, deep clean between teeth and neutralize plaque acids. Naturally-sourced Calcium helps repair enamel.

Additionally, essential oils were added to freshen breath for a whole mouth-clean feel.

Buy Now
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
04/19/2024 12:03 am GMT

Dentist Review

The mint flavor was pronounced and most flavorful compared to the other two toothpaste.

Also, the baking soda “experience” was less intense. Natural ingredients are a great benefit, as many kinds of toothpaste are transitioning in this direction.

After rinsing, a comfortable cooling effect leaves your mouth feeling rejuvenated and refreshed. The whitening aspects of this toothpaste are beneficial.

However, it leaves our teeth slightly more sensitive to sweets and cold. Also, the toothpaste's texture is considerably gritty compared to the other two options.

Highlights

  • Sodium fluoride 0.24%
  • 100% natural baking soda
  • Fresh mint flavor
  • White and strengthened teeth
  • Free of artificial sweeteners, preservatives and dyes
  • Free of Sodium lauryl sulfate and parabens
  • 2X stronger enamel
  • Two shades whiter teeth

Results

Effectiveness0
Comfort0
Taste0
Likability0
Total0

Best for patients that desire natural ingredients and whitening benefits.


3. Best Complete Care | Arm & Hammer CompleteCare Toothpaste

Best Complete Care
Arm & Hammer Complete Care Toothpaste
$3.98 ($0.66 / Ounce)

Arm & Hammer is committed to being environmentally responsible and donates a portion of its profits to charities.

Also, they recently announced a new Essentials line, free of artificial sweeteners, sodium lauryl sulfate, preservatives, parabens, and dyes.

All but one of their toothpaste contains sodium fluoride 0.24% anticavity protection (Essentials Activated Charcoal is fluoride-free). The baking soda and peroxide experience is unique and provides a rejuvenating feel.

Buy Now
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
04/19/2024 11:20 am GMT

Dentist Review

The CompleteCare toothpaste was surprisingly smooth and gentle on the gums.

The smooth texture allowed the toothbrush to glide over all the teeth without irritating the gums. It has a great aftertaste, and the flavor is refreshing.

Lastly, the foaming action effectively removed plaque acid and neutralized the mouth. Although the texture was smooth and comfortable, it did have the most robust baking soda flavor; however, some individuals may desire this unique aspect.

Highlights

  • Sodium fluoride 0.24%
  • Fresh mint flavor
  • Baking soda neutralizes acid
  • Strengthens enamel
  • Proven whitening

Results

Effectiveness0
Comfort0
Taste0
Likability0
Total0

Best for patients with sensitive teeth and gums.


Overall Champion | Arm & Hammer PeroxiCare Toothpaste*

Best Overall
Arm & Hammer Peroxicare Toothpaste
$8.99 ($0.75 / Ounce)

ARM & HAMMER™ Peroxicare™ anticavity fluoride toothpaste is the ultimate deep cleaning formula that improves gum health, protects against cavities and gently whitens teeth.

Naturally powered by 100% pure baking soda, this toothpaste goes beyond cleaning, giving you stronger, healthier teeth and gums.

Unlike regular fluoride toothpaste, the pure baking soda formulas penetrate deeper throughout your mouth, REMOVING UP TO 3X MORE PLAQUE in hard-to-reach places.

Buy Now
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
04/18/2024 11:03 pm GMT

Final Thoughts

All three Arm & Hammer products provided an exceptional clean with unique foaming action.

The “experience” I was referring to pertains to baking soda and peroxide's effects on the germs in your mouth.

Similarly to the popular Pop Rocks candy, it offers “results you can feel working.” After using their products, you feel comfortable that your mouth will be fresh and clean.

PeroxiCare edged out CompleteCare and Essentials because of its smooth texture, mint flavor, and overall effectiveness.

Essentials offer a distinct gritty texture that seeks to whiten and strengthen the enamel; however, it may lead to sensitive teeth, so avoid this product if that’s you.

Lastly, CompleteCare is recommended for sensitive gums, as it is the most comfortable to use. Its creamy smooth texture allowed the toothbrush to glide over all aspects of the teeth.

Final Rankings

  1. Arm & Hammer PeroxiCare Toothpaste 19/20
  2. Arm & Hammer CompleteCare Toothpaste 18/20
  3. Arm & Hammer Essentials Whiten & Strengthen Toothpaste 17/20

* My Dental Advocate product reviews are based on individual experience and your results with the products may vary.

Need a second opinion? We can help! Learn more. Knowledge is power when cultivating healthy dental habits. The more informed you are, the better positioned you'll be to prevent avoidable and potentially costly dental procedures for you and your family. Watch for future blog posts, where we'll continue sharing important information, product reviews and practical advice!

About the Author

Dr. Matthew Hannan, also known as “Dr. Advocate,” is a board-certified dentist on a mission to provide accurate dental patient education. He attended Baylor University before completing dental school at UT Health San Antonio School of Dentistry. He now lives in Arizona with his beautiful wife and 4 kids. Dr. Hannan believes everyone should access easy-to-read dental resources with relevant, up-to-date dental research and insight to improve their oral health.

Matt Hannan, DDS Signature | My Dental Advocate

Connect with Dr. Hannan!

5 Best Toothbrush for Braces | My Dental Advocate
Adult Dentistry | Buying Guide | Dr. Advocate’s Insight | Oral Health

5 Best Toothbrush for Braces 2024 (Dentist Recommended)

Are you navigating through the bristles of finding the perfect toothbrush for braces? Fear not! Our curated list of the top best toothbrushes for braces is your roadmap to achieving pristine oral hygiene while keeping those braces sparkling clean. Embark on a journey toward a brighter smile!

BetterMouth 30-Day Review (Dentist Recommended) | My Dental Advocate
Adult Dentistry | Buying Guide | Dental Tips | Dr. Advocate’s Insight | Oral Health | Product Review

BetterMouth 30-Day Review (Dentist-Recommended)

Discover a Smarter Way to Dental Health with BetterMouth: This innovative app offers a personalized approach to oral hygiene! It transforms your daily routine into a guided journey towards better dental care. But does it live up to the hype? Let’s find out.

Gain Clarity with Our FREE Second Opinion Guide

Unsure About Your Dental Diagnosis?

Receive clear, expert second opinions online within 48 hours. Start today!

5 star rating
5 star rating
5 star rating
5 star rating
5 star rating
“My five-year-old son was experiencing severe pain in his mouth and jaw region that required me to pull him from school and take him to his on-call doctor. We didn’t receive any official answers from his doctor visit but My Dental Advocate service was so helpful! Utilizing this service gave me peace of mind as a mother.”
(Received Clarity)
Krista
Arizona
5 star rating
5 star rating
5 star rating
5 star rating
5 star rating
“I reached out to My Dental Advocate for a second opinion after finding them online. They quickly responded with a full report informing me that they agreed with the findings and even explained why it needed to be extracted. I highly recommend them for an online second opinion!”
(Saved $3000)
Rita
Texas
5 star rating
5 star rating
5 star rating
5 star rating
5 star rating
“I was on an extended trip traveling for work, and went to a corporate dental office that I was unfamiliar with. Upon performing an x-ray, they identified a few inclusions and were pressing me to schedule. With My Dental Advocate, I was able to get a second opinion and feel more confident about the urgency of treatment.”
(Received Clarity)
Michael
California

Product Reviews

Our 250+ dental product reviews (and counting), curated by an experienced dentist, are the most comprehensive online.

Toothbrush Genie

State-of-the-art chatbot designed to help you discover your perfect toothbrush in just a few simple steps!

Cavity Risk Assessment

Cutting-edge digital tool designed to evaluate your individual cavity risk based on your responses to a series of questions.

Gum Disease Assessment

Discover your gum disease risk with our quick and engaging 6-question assessment!

Product Reviews
Blog Posts
Money Saved

Easiest Second Opinion, Ever!

  • Confidently upload x-rays (plus any other documents) to a board-certified dentist via HIPAA-secure email.
  • Within 48 hours, you receive an expert second opinion affirming your current treatment plan or recommending alternative treatment options.